Welcome to Colonial Pizza
Colonial Pizza, nestled at 400 S 43rd St in Philadelphia, is a beloved local gem renowned for its inviting atmosphere and exceptional fare. With an impressive menu featuring everything from classic pizzas to hearty hot platters and delectable milkshakes, this spot truly excels in comfort food. Customer reviews praise the friendly, attentive staff and the high quality of dishes—from the irresistibly crispy pizzas to the loaded cheesesteaks. Whether you're craving a cheese-stuffed Stromboli or a refreshing malt shake, Colonial Pizza delivers consistently delicious meals that make it a standout choice in University City.
-
400 S 43rd St, Philadelphia, PA 19104, United States400 S 43rd St, Philadelphia, PA 19104, United States Hotline: +1 215-387-7702
Welcome to Colonial Pizza, a beloved culinary institution located at 400 S 43rd St, Philadelphia, PA. Renowned for its quality and warm atmosphere, this local pizza shop stands as a beacon of classic comfort food in University City. With a firm belief that great meals bring people together, Colonial Pizza has become a cherished gathering spot for families, friends, and students alike.
Colonial Pizza offers a menu that caters to all cravings. From their indulgent Eggplant Parm with melted mozzarella and savory tomato sauce to the hearty Baked Ziti Bolognese featuring homemade zesty meat sauce, each dish is crafted with care and served alongside their famous garlic knots. Pizzas are not just food here; they're an experience, highlighted by a perfectly thin, crispy crust reminiscent of the best NYC slices. Diners rave about the pepperoni Stromboli, generously filled with cheese, peppers, and onions, ensuring that every bite is packed with flavor.
The atmosphere is as warm as the food, thanks to the friendly, accommodating staff. They take the time to ensure each guest feels welcomed and valued, often remembering regular orders, which adds a personal touch to every visit. Customers frequently compliment the quick service, even during busy events like Porchfest, where the team impressively manages to keep up with demand. It’s this commitment to service and quality that keeps patrons returning time after time.
Not to be overlooked, Colonial Pizza’s cheesesteaks, including the Buffalo Chicken Cheese Steak and the Colonial Chicken loaded with pepperoni, mushrooms, and fresh veggies, hold their own against any worthy competitors in Philadelphia. The flavors are robust, and the portions generous, making them an essential part of the menu.
In a city filled with pizza options, Colonial Pizza emerges as a go-to destination for quality and value without pretension. Whether you're stopping in for a casual meal, grabbing a quick slice, or looking to enjoy some of the best comfort food around, Colonial Pizza is sure to leave you satisfied and wanting more. So, gather your friends, order a cheesesteak, indulge in a slice, and soak in the atmosphere at this quintessential neighborhood gem.
I just tried to go to allegro pizza and walked out, realizing what a mistake I made even trying places that aren’t colonial. For me Colonial is the quality bar that other places need to exceed to be considered good at this point. This place is great. Reasonable prices, friendly and accommodating staff, great food. What more could you ask for in your local hole-in-the-wall pizza joint? Couldn’t recommend this place enough. Get the chicken parm!
Friendly staff. They don't rush you through your order. I ordered pepperoni Stromboli and it was fresh and hot when delivered. Generous amount of cheese and pepperoni and onions and green peppers. The best pizza shop in University City!!!
Great neighborhood institution. Good food. Good neighbors. These guys always bring their a-game. High quality delicious fresh hot pizza and wings. I feel like they take pride in their food. They treat me and my boys like family.
I came here during porchfest this year, and their service was SO fast, AND they had public bathrooms open to the crowd! I wasn't expecting much because of the insanely busy crowd, but our pizzas came out with a perfectly thin crispy crust just like you'd find in NYC. They were so good we went back for second slices! They were totally swamped but handled the crowd without any flaws. Michelin stars better watch out. Who needs fancy neopolitan pizza when you have a perfectly fine neighborhood joint? Great job, staff!
look no further for your go-to, salt of the earth pizza shop. it’s not going to be anything fancy, but it will be a very good version of a classic takeaway pizza. staff is good people and always super sweet and will even remember ur order! also have to shout out the cheesesteaks, they are go-to for me in all of philadelphia. stop in, get a milkshake, and enjoy watching the lively street corner from the window booth—you’ll be glad you did!
Neighborhood spot on my block. They've got crispy crinkle fries! And the Italian Burger was excellent. I especially liked that they toasted the bun on the flattop. My food took all of 10 minutes on a Thursday evening at 8pm. The staff is always friendly :) buena gente.
Stopped here for their lunch deal: two slices of pizza and a can of soda for 7. Generous portions, really good pizza. It’s the best in the area I’ve had so far, thin crust and solid sauce.
Amazing neighborhood pizza place. The delivery service is almost always fast and the food is consistently very good. Prices are also decent. The delivery drivers are also very nice and considerate.